> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://werd.io/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Islands, tagging, and an ocean-like inbox
- URL: https://werd.io/islands-tagging-and-an-ocean-like-inbox/
- Published: 2006-07-04T09:02:19.000Z
- Updated: 2025-06-12T11:01:19.000Z
- Author: Ben Werdmuller
- Tags: General, #ben-684a32da145d7d001be71dae, #Migrated-1749693130536, #wp, #wp-post, #Import 2025-06-11 21:52

[![Zzz](http://static.flickr.com/47/180827081_1fa8516ba7_m.jpg)](http://www.flickr.com/photos/benwerd/180827081/)

I spent the (unexpectedly long) weekend on a small Cornish island nature reserve where my sister is assistant warden. Downtime is good, but now I'm very much back in action, with a long list of things to do and slightly more time to do it in.

One change I've just made to the way I work is that I've ditched Gmail in favour of Mozilla Thunderbird as my email interface. I'm still using Gmail's servers (largely so I have a backup with a nice web interface that I can use when I don't have my laptop), but using Thunderbird allows me to file mail how I want it. Gmail's constant stream of messages with only the search box and labels as a filing mechanism just doesn't work for me; I need more order.

This is an important lesson. Labels are effectively tags, and you can click on labels as if they were folders to get a filtered view, but I find for mail messages the folder metaphor works better for me. I'm disinclined to use the filtered views when I see unread mail in the main window, and as a result I have a horrible tendency to read mail, think I'll come back to it later, and never look at it again. Thunderbird - or any software mail client - allows you to keep something in the inbox until you've dealt with it, and then file it away appropriately. That, for me, leads to a more efficient way of working.

Which isn't to say that tags aren't useful in this context; it'd be handy for me to be able to search across folders on the keyword 'elgg', for obvious reasons. I might have a folder for the development mailing list, another one for discussions with Dave, and so on, but there are likely times when I want to see all of these messages grouped together.

My thinking, then, is that tagging should sit *alongside* other sorting mechanisms, but generally isn't enough as a replacement. That doesn't mean I've suddenly started believing in top-down ontologies as dictated by institutions (except in very specific cases); I don't. Users must control the way their data is stored. But part of this is for people to use the method that best suits them, and I think there's room for many approaches.